A comprehensive chronology of Greenwell’s criminal record, violent offenses, confirmed victims, and the decades-long investigation that finally identified him
Visit ACJ Investigates: The I-65 Killer for our I-65 Killer/Days Inn Murders Archive.
For decades, the man known as the I-65 Serial Killer existed only as a composite sketch, a collection of crime scene reports, and an unidentified DNA profile. Investigators knew he had murdered motel clerks, sexually assaulted survivors, and operated across multiple states, but they did not know his name.
That changed on April 5, 2022, when investigators announced that Harry Edward Greenwell had been identified through forensic genealogy as the offender responsible for the murders of Vicki Heath, Margaret “Peggy” Gill, Jeanne Gilbert, and the violent assaults of two surviving victims in Indiana and Minnesota.
The identification answered one question but raised another: How does a man accumulate decades of arrests, escapes, robberies, violence against women, and repeated contacts with the criminal justice system without being connected to a series of murders and sexual assaults stretching across the Midwest?
This timeline examines the known life and criminal history of Harry Edward Greenwell, from his earliest documented offenses as a juvenile through his arrests, escapes, domestic violence incidents, and the crimes now attributed to the I-65 Serial Killer. It also traces the decades-long investigation that ultimately identified him years after his death.
The chronology is based on court records, newspaper archives, law enforcement statements, and investigative reporting. While Greenwell has been identified as the offender responsible for the confirmed I-65 murders and assaults, questions remain about the full scope of his criminal activity and whether additional victims have yet to be identified.1960–1982: Early Criminal Career
1960–1982: Early Criminal Career
August 1960: Church Burglary, Police Pursuit, and Crash
At fifteen years old, Harry Edward Greenwell was detained following a police pursuit involving convicted felon Burnes Arnold Stinson. Police recovered approximately $1,200 in stolen church property after the vehicle crashed during the chase. This represents one of the earliest documented incidents involving Greenwell and serious criminal activity.
October 1962: Escape from Kentucky Village
Greenwell and two other juveniles escaped from Kentucky Village Youth Detention Center and stole a vehicle from Spring Valley Country Club. No additional charges appear to have been filed for the theft.
April 12, 1963: Robbery Conviction
Greenwell pleaded guilty to robbery and received a five-year suspended sentence. The conviction would later resurface after another escape and probation violation.
March 1–2, 1965: Courthouse Escape and Capture
While being held in Jefferson County, Greenwell escaped by kicking out a second-story window screen and jumping approximately twenty feet. Less than twenty-four hours later he was captured at a Greyhound Bus Depot restaurant in Elizabethtown. Prosecutors subsequently sought revocation of his suspended robbery sentence.
August 1977: Reports Being Robbed
Greenwell reported being robbed of approximately $400 by several armed men. Though not a criminal charge against him, the incident illustrates his continued interaction with law enforcement and criminal environments.
June–July 1982: Iowa Jail Escape
Greenwell escaped from the Allamakee County Jail in Iowa. Following a manhunt, he was captured hiding on a farm near Lansing. He was later sentenced to two years imprisonment for the escape.
1987–1991: The I-65 Serial Killer Murders and Assaults
February 21, 1987: Murder of Vicki Heath
Forty-one-year-old motel clerk Vicki Heath was robbed, sexually assaulted, and murdered while working alone at a Super 8 Motel in Elizabethtown, Kentucky. Decades later DNA evidence would identify Greenwell as the offender.
March 3, 1989: Murder of Peggy Gill
Margaret “Peggy” Gill was robbed, sexually assaulted, and murdered while working the overnight shift at a Days Inn in Merrillville, Indiana.
March 3, 1989: Murder of Jeanne Gilbert
Just hours later, Jeanne Gilbert was abducted from the Remington Days Inn, sexually assaulted, and murdered. Her body was discovered approximately nineteen miles away in rural White County.
March 24–26, 1989: Domestic Violence Arrests
Three weeks after the murders of Gill and Gilbert, Greenwell was arrested after allegedly kicking in a door, dragging his estranged wife from a residence, strangling her, and threatening her in public. After release on bond, he was arrested again for violating no-contact conditions.
January 2, 1990: Columbus Days Inn Assault
A twenty-one-year-old hotel clerk survived a robbery, sexual assault, and attempted murder at a Days Inn in Columbus, Indiana. Her description would later produce the most recognizable composite sketch associated with the I-65 Serial Killer.
1991: Rochester Assault
A Minnesota woman survived a robbery, sexual assault, and stabbing attack. DNA evidence would later connect the offender to the murders of Heath, Gill, Gilbert, and the Columbus survivor.
1992–1998: Life After the Known Attacks
Throughout the 1990s
Investigators across multiple states continued pursuing leads in the Days Inn murders and associated assaults. Greenwell remained unidentified despite his extensive criminal record and prior arrests.
October 14, 1998: Stepdaughter Stabbing and Firearm Arrest
Greenwell was involved in an incident in which his fifteen-year-old stepdaughter stabbed him. Authorities also arrested him for possession of a firearm despite his status as a convicted felon. Questions remain regarding the final disposition of the case and the firearm recovered.
1999–2013: Cold Case Investigation
2000–2010: DNA Advances
Advances in forensic science allowed investigators to connect previously separate crimes committed in Kentucky and Indiana.
2010: Vicki Heath Linked Through DNA
DNA evidence linked the 1987 murder of Vicki Heath to the same offender responsible for the Days Inn murders and the Columbus assault.
2013: Rochester DNA Match
Investigators confirmed that DNA recovered from the Rochester assault matched the same offender profile connected to the other crimes.
January 31, 2013: Death of Harry Edward Greenwell
Greenwell died before investigators publicly identified him as the offender responsible for the murders and assaults.
2019–2022: Identification
2019–2022: Investigative Genetic Genealogy
Investigators used forensic genealogy to identify Greenwell as the offender responsible for the I-65 murders and associated assaults.
April 5, 2022: Public Identification
Indiana State Police, the FBI, and partner agencies announced that Harry Edward Greenwell had been identified as the offender responsible for the murders of Vicki Heath, Peggy Gill, Jeanne Gilbert, and the violent assaults in Columbus and Rochester.
Present
Harry Edward Greenwell was never prosecuted for the I-65 Serial Killer murders because he died in 2013. While investigators identified him through DNA and genetic genealogy, questions remain about the full extent of his criminal activity, additional possible victims, and whether opportunities existed to identify him decades earlier.
